Patent Verdict in Marshall

In a scene somewhat less relaxing than this one canoeing at Fern in December, a Marshall jury in Judge Gilstrap’s court returned a verdict in the ATL v. CosMX case last Friday. All four claims were found infringed, but two were proven invalid. At least one of the four was willfully infringed (yes, I know what you’re thinking and no, we don’t know from the verdict form whether it was the ones that were not found invalid). Damages were set at $3,701,108. The jury also found that a letter by the plaintiff was not shown by clear and convincing evidence to be both objectively baseless and an attempt to interfere with a business relationship of a competitor through use of the litigation process, nor did the plaintiff engage in anticompetitive conduct.